On Wednesday the FIFA U-17 World Cup kicks off in Doha for the second year running, and once again the Aspire Zone becomes the centre of world youth football: 48 national teams, 104 matches between 19 November and 13 December, and up to eight games a day during the group stage. On 11 November FIFA published the official squad lists for all 48 teams, over 1,000 players in total, each with a date of birth. For anyone who studies talent identification, that is one of the largest, cleanest and fully public relative age datasets in youth sport, being played out a few kilometres from my office.
So I asked two questions. First, does doubling the tournament from 24 to 48 teams dilute the classic birth-quartile skew, or simply spread it to more federations? Second, which nations and positions break the pattern? And then a third question, the one I think matters most for practitioners: if these squads are the most skewed cohort in the pathway, how much does that skew actually tell us about who will become a senior international?
A quick refresher on relative age
Youth competitions group players by a fixed cut-off date. For this tournament that means players born on or after 1 January 2009. A player born in January is almost a full year older than a teammate born in December, and at 15–17 years of age that year can mean several centimetres of height, kilograms of muscle mass and a very different stage of maturation. Coaches selecting for today’s match tend to pick the bigger, faster, more mature players, and those are disproportionately the ones born early in the selection year. The result is the relative age effect (RAE): an over-representation of players born in the first quarter (Q1, January–March) and an under-representation of those born in the last quarter (Q4, October–December).
It is one of the most replicated findings in sport science, but the magnitude is not fixed. It varies by age group, sex, position, country and level of competition, and that variation is where the interesting questions are.
What 1,000-plus birthdates show
I extracted date of birth and playing position for every player in the official FIFA squad list (48 teams × 21 players = 1,008), assigned each to a birth quarter and compared the observed distribution with what we would expect if birth month were irrelevant to selection (an even spread, weighted for the number of days in each quarter). For comparison I did the same for the 1,008 players at the 2025 edition.
The result is about as clear as relative age data get. In 2026, 40.5% of players were born in January–March and only 14.2% in October–December (Q2 25.8%, Q3 19.5%). A Q1 player is almost three times as likely to be in a squad as a Q4 player: the Q1:Q4 odds ratio is 2.9 (95% CI 2.4–3.5; χ² = 163, p < 0.001; Cramér’s V = 0.23, a small-to-moderate effect).
There is a second, cruder layer of relative age hiding in these squads. The tournament is open to anyone born in 2009 or later, so in principle 15- and 16-year-olds could compete for places. In practice 80% of the 2026 players were born in 2009, the oldest eligible year (84% of the 2025 players were born in 2008). So the selection funnel favours the oldest year of the window, and then the oldest months within that year.
By confederation and by position
Previous work at this level suggests we should not expect a uniform picture. When Romann and Fuchslocher analysed 672 players at the FIFA U-17 Women’s World Cup, they found significant RAEs in the European and North/Central American zones, none in Asia, Oceania and South America, and significant inverse RAEs among African players. The usual suspects for these differences are the structure of national pathways, how early formal selection begins, school-year versus calendar-year grouping, and the reliability of birth registration in some countries.
Pooling both editions to give each confederation a reasonable sample, the gradient is striking. UEFA squads show the strongest effect: 47% of European players were born in Q1 and fewer than 9% in Q4, an odds ratio of 5.6 (4.0–7.8). Oceania (4.2), South America (4.0), CONCACAF (3.0) and Asia (2.7) follow. African squads are the exception: their distribution is close to flat (Q1 30.7%, Q4 25.0%; odds ratio 1.2, 95% CI 1.0–1.6), and in neither edition on its own does the African skew reach statistical significance.
I would be careful about reading the African result as “no relative age bias”. It is consistent with Romann and Fuchslocher’s findings, but birth registration is part of the story: 13 of the 420 African players (3.1%) have a registered birthday of 1 January or 31 December, roughly six times what chance would predict, a possible marker of estimated or administratively assigned birthdates. When birthdates are partly administrative, the birth-quarter signal is diluted. Maturation-related selection may still be operating; we just can’t see it through the calendar.
At team level, the most skewed 2026 squads are the USA (15 of 21 players born in Q1, none in Q4), Italy (14 Q1, one Q4), China, France and Denmark (13, 12 and 12 Q1 players respectively, none in Q4). At the other end, Côte d’Ivoire, Senegal, Uganda and Tanzania have as many or more Q4 than Q1 players. Japan is a neat case study: its squad has more April–June than January–March births, which is what you would expect in a system where the school year, and much youth football, starts on 1 April.
Position matters less than I expected. In Italian Serie A rosters, the Q1 over-representation was strongest among goalkeepers (odds ratio 4.4), and goalkeeping is the position where height counts most and where selection decisions are often made earliest. Pooled across both tournaments, goalkeepers do have the highest odds ratio (3.4, 95% CI 2.3–4.9), but defenders (2.9), midfielders (2.8) and forwards (2.6) are not far behind and the confidence intervals overlap substantially. The goalkeeper effect was large in 2025 (4.9) and unremarkable in 2026 (2.6), which is a good reminder that 144 goalkeepers per edition is not a big sample. At this level, relative age is a squad-wide filter, not a positional quirk.
2025 vs 2026: is the skew stable?
Qatar hosts this tournament every year until 2029, which is a rare opportunity: five consecutive editions of the same 48-team format, at the same venues, with public squad lists. Comparing the 2025 and 2026 cohorts tells us whether the RAE at this level is a stable structural feature or something that fluctuates with the particular group of federations that qualify.
The answer, so far, is that it is remarkably stable. The 2025 squads had 40.3% Q1 and 14.9% Q4 births (odds ratio 2.8, 95% CI 2.3–3.3); the 2026 squads 40.5% and 14.2% (2.9, 2.4–3.5). That is despite roughly a third of the qualified nations changing between editions. Individual confederations move around more (UEFA 6.3 → 5.0, CONCACAF 2.3 → 3.8, Oceania 6.7 → 2.8, the last on only 63 players per year), but the overall picture, and the European-high, African-low ordering, does not. That is what a structural effect looks like: it comes from how youth football everywhere is organised, not from which countries happened to qualify.
So, to the opening question: doubling the field has not diluted the skew. The expanded format simply exposes the same filter in more federations.
Why the U-17 skew overstates its own importance
Here is the part I want coaches and federations to take away. A strong RAE in a U-17 squad tells us a lot about how players are selected at 16. It tells us much less about who becomes a senior international.
In our analysis of 885 players selected for Italian youth and senior national teams between 2000 and 2021, the Q1:Q4 odds ratio was around 9 at U16 and fell to about 1.7 in the senior team. Looked at retrospectively, only a small minority of youth internationals (less than 10–20%) went on to be selected for the senior team, and most senior players had never been selected for youth national teams. The RAE was also smaller among players who successfully transitioned. In other words, the birthdate filter is strongest exactly where it is least predictive.
A recent longitudinal study by Nisbet and colleagues in Biology of Sport, covering 1,518 male and 487 female players in a national programme, adds nuance. Senior teams still showed an RAE (odds ratios of 2.27 for men and 1.50 for women), and youth-to-senior transition rates were 20% for males and 30% for females. Strikingly, males born in Q1 had the lowest transition rate of any quartile (17%). What predicted transition was opportunity: each additional youth-team appearance increased the likelihood of progressing to the senior team by 19.4%.
The Serie A data point the same way from the other end. Q1 players are over-represented in professional rosters, yet once players are inside the professional environment there are no differences between birth quartiles in appearances, playing time or consistency of selection. The bias operates at the selection gate, not in the coach’s weekly team sheet.
We have seen similar patterns outside football. In world-class middle- and long-distance runners, only around one in five top U18 athletes reached the senior top 50, and in sprint swimming the early-success athletes tended to plateau around 20 years of age while later developers kept improving. Success at 16 is a weak signal, and youth selection systems that treat it as a strong one will keep discarding late-born and late-maturing players who would have been competitive at 23.
Practical takeaways for federations selecting U-17 squads
- Audit your own birth distribution every cycle. It takes an afternoon with a spreadsheet, and the numbers start better conversations with selectors than any lecture on RAE.
- Measure maturation, not just age. Simple non-invasive estimates of maturity status let selectors see whether a player’s dominance is talent or timing, and bio-banded training and games can reveal what late developers can do when they are not physically outmatched.
- Protect playing opportunities. If youth appearances predict transition, then rotating minutes and keeping a wider pool of late-born players involved is not charity; it is better talent management.
- Don’t treat a youth cap as a filter for the senior team. Most senior internationals were never youth internationals. Keep the door open and track players who were not selected.
- Changing the cut-off date is not a fix. Moving from calendar year to school year simply relocates the advantaged birth months, as Japan’s April-heavy squad illustrates. The effect is structural, so the solution has to be in how selection decisions are made.
What’s next
With five consecutive editions in Doha, the obvious follow-up is longitudinal: track the 2025 squads into senior national-team caps over the next few years and test directly whether birth quarter at U-17 predicts senior selection. I’ll come back to that as the data accumulate. In the meantime, enjoy the football at Aspire, and when you watch the squads line up, have a look at who was born in January and who was born in December.
Methods note
2026 data: FIFA’s official squad list PDF (all 48 teams, 1,008 players; a sample of teams was re-extracted independently and matched exactly). 2025 data: the squad tables on Wikipedia’s 2025 FIFA U-17 World Cup squads page (48 teams, 1,008 players), a secondary source. Expected quarter frequencies are weighted by days per quarter; I did not adjust for national birth-seasonality, which varies modestly between countries. Odds ratios compare observed Q1:Q4 counts with the expected ratio, with Wald 95% confidence intervals. Positions are as listed by FIFA (GK, DF, MF, FW).
References
- Boccia G, Brustio PR, Rinaldi R, Romagnoli R, Cardinale M, Piacentini MF (2023). Junior to senior transition pathway in Italian football: the rocky road to the top is not determined by youth national team’s selections. PLoS One 18(7): e0288594. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0288594
- Brustio PR, Stival M, Cardinale M, Mulasso A, Rainoldi A, Boccia G (2024). Performance pathways in elite middle- and long-distance track and field athletes: the influence of a successful youth. Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport 27(9): 654–659. doi:10.1016/j.jsams.2024.05.007
- Brustio PR, Cardinale M, Lupo C, Boccia G (2022). Don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater: talent in swimming sprinting events might be hidden at early age. International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance 17(11): 1550–1557. doi:10.1123/ijspp.2021-0530
- Brustio PR, Ungureanu AN, Beratto L, Li Volsi D, Lupo C (2026). Relative age selection bias does not translate into a playing-time advantage: evidence from Italian Serie A football. Frontiers in Psychology 16: 1733277. doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1733277
- Nisbet D, Mandorino M, Zmijewski P, Modric T, Teixeira J, Moreira A, Morgans R (2026). The relative age effect and transition rates across a national soccer program in male and female youth to senior players: a longitudinal analysis. Biology of Sport 43(1): 439–448. doi:10.5114/biolsport.2026.154941
- Romann M, Fuchslocher J (2013). Influences of player nationality, playing position, and height on relative age effects at women’s under-17 FIFA World Cup. Journal of Sports Sciences 31(1): 32–40. doi:10.1080/02640414.2012.718442
- FIFA (11 November 2026). The FIFA U-17 World Cup Qatar 2026 official squad lists confirmed. inside.fifa.com
Data sources: FIFA official squad lists, U-17 World Cup Qatar 2026; 2025 FIFA U-17 World Cup squads (Wikipedia).

















You must be logged in to post a comment.